Free Consultation: 800.722.0383

800.722.0383

N.J. Woman Awarded $4M in Old Bridge Bus Crash Lawsuit

By Spencer Kent | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com

OLD BRIDGE — A woman who was left permanently disabled after a school bus rear-ended a commuter bus in 2013 received a $4 million payout from a settlement reached in a lawsuit.

Christine Carhuff, 36, of Freehold, who was a passenger on the commuter bus, filed a lawsuit in the summer of 2013 against the school bus’ owner, the Old Bridge Board of Education.

The driver of the school bus and the commuter bus were also named as defendants in the lawsuit.

Old Bridge Township and the company of the commuter bus will each pay $2 million, according to Carhuff’s attorney, Andrew John Calcagno. Old Bridge must pay by March and Academy must pay by April.

There was no admission of wrongdoing or liability in the settlement.

“I advised both defendants that if they did not pay the $4 million that we were picking a jury (for a trial),” Calcagno said.

The crash happened during the height of the morning traffic rush on Jan. 10, 2013.

According to previous reports, the bus was owned by Academy. However, as part of the settlement, the company was not named as part of a confidentiality agreement.

The commuter bus, which was carrying about 30 people, rear-ended the 24-seat school bus, causing it to smash into a tree and throw passengers from their seats. No children were on board the school bus at the time.

Man who fell in supermarket bags $1.2M settlement: Report

The bankrupt grocer paid the settlement in January.
The crash — which was captured on video by a camera video from the commuter bus — caused the school bus, driven by Tracy Dehart, to flip over and hit a generator and pumping station off the highway, leaving her and a school aide with minor injuries.

The lawsuit alleged that the driver of the commuter bus, Daniel Jean-Pierre, of Barnegat, was negligent in the crash by failing to maintain control of the vehicle. Jean-Pierre also suffered serious injuries in the incident, officials said at the time.

Carhuff was permanently disabled from the crash after sustaining multiple fractures and injuries to her neck, shoulder, lower back, leg and ankle, requiring multiple surgeries, according to Calcagno.

Calcagno said his client was pleased with the outcome of the settlement.

“Christine is very happy she has finality and that she will have enough money to support herself for the rest of her life,” Calcagno said.

Jean-Pierre’s attorney, Jack A. Maloof, declined to comment on the matter. Attorneys representing the township’s Board of Education and school bus driver did not return a call seeking comment.

Township Mayor Owen Henry and the Old Bridge Board of Education were also unavailable for comment.

Spencer Kent may be reached at [email protected] Follow him on Twitter @SpencerMKent. Find the Find NJ.com on Facebook.

Full Article With Photos

BLOG

Firm Blog


  • Top 3 Causes of Emergency Room Malpractice

    September 28, 2017

    Emergency rooms are busy places. While doctors and staff in most emergency rooms work hard to provide appropriate care to every patient, errors that result in substandard care can still occur. When these errors cause injuries, medical malpractice can result. Here are the top three causes of medical malpractice claims in emergency rooms: Misdiagnosis of […] Read More


  • Electronic Cigarettes Can Be Defective and Dangerous

    September 21, 2017

    Electronic cigarettes have become popular as a way for smokers to ease their nicotine cravings without inhaling the many additives and particulates emitted by conventional tobacco cigarettes. And while e-cigarettes might not pose the same risks as conventional cigarettes, certain types of e-cigarettes have been found to contain dangerous hidden defects that can cause severe […] Read More


  • How Can a Forceps Birth Cause Injury?

    September 13, 2017

    Forceps are a medical tool that resembles a large, curved pair of salad tongs. They are used to help guide a baby through the birth canal when a prolonged second phase of labor, exhaustion, or other factors prevent the birthing parent from completing delivery alone. While not all children born with the use of forceps […] Read More

View More Blogs

$4.7 M

Verdict - Train Accident

Plaintiff suffered multiple injuries, including a fractured skull that resulted in a large epidural hematoma requiring an emergency craniotomy after a New Jersey Transit train accident.

$4.0 M

Payout - Bus Crash

Plaintiff sustained multiple fractures and injuries to her shoulder, neck, lower back, leg, and ankle after a bus accident. She required multiple surgeries which still resulted in permanent damage.

$2.5 M

Recovery - Head On Collision

Paintiff suffered multiple injuries, including a right temporal skull fracture, requiring a temporal craniotomy; post-traumatic seizure disorder; and post-traumatic stress disorder.

$2.0 M

Settlement - Wrongful Death

Plaintiff sustained multiple fractures and injuries to her shoulder, neck, lower back, leg, and ankle after a bus accident. She required multiple surgeries which still resulted in permanent damage.

View More Case Results

Thank you!

Someone from our office will contact you shortly

“The amount of pride and overall care he has for his clients is felt immediately. When I first meet him, I never felt rushed or pressured to sign up with him. Andrew and his staff are caring, knowledgable people that make you feel at home.”
- Louis